WTF ... IS WTF!?
We are a collective of people who believe in freedom of speech, the rights of individuals, and free pancakes! We share our lives, struggles, frustrations, successes, joys, and prescribe to our own special brand of humor and insanity. If you are looking for a great place to hang out, make new friends, find new nemeses, and just be yourself, WTF.com is your new home.

Intel vs AMD / Nvidia vs ATI

#1
I'm thinking of buying a very good gaming computer, and have heard many things concerning these cards about gaming. Of course, these opinions have been biased. Is there any real distinction in the processors or graphics cards that make them better than the other one for graphics intensive games? If so, which ones excell in which fields, etc.
 
2,489
332
327
#2
i'm not sure, but i hear that amd athalon 64 and nvidia 6800 will make a good combination :thumbsup: or you can just buy an alienware.
 

Descent

Hella Constipated
7,686
109
157
#3
The Athlon 64 as of right now is the best gaming CPU, and for the money ATi's Radeon X800 XL is the best deal.

For balls out, ass-kicking performance though, an nVidia 6800 SLi solution is unbeatable.

Dull_Bullet said:
or you can just buy an alienware.
Those aren't as fast as a competitively priced system from most other manufacturers, and they aren't very reliable. As of late, Abit has gone downhill, and they supply Alienware with their motherboards.

In fact, my friend's Alienware's Abit popped and died the third day he got it, and he's still awaiting replacement.

Also, their new case that they introduced to replace their Antec case back from 2002 has a myriad of heat issues, everything from poor conductivity to nasty airflow. Fortunately, it's not enough to impair operation...

My other "friend's" Alienware was like a Kenmore Space Heater at the LAN party, and I swear my leg was about to fall off :(.

He has a 3.2 P4 and a 9800XT in his, it's an older unit, but much more reliable than their new ones.

Personally I use Chaintech and Asus boards, and a Gigabyte here and there.
 

Jung

???
Premium
13,980
1,398
487
#4
I'm partial to AMD and Nvidia. For processors, AMD's 64 series is the best performance for it's price range. They consistently come out on top in gaming benchmarks. I wouldn't go with an Intel unless you do a lot of media encoding.

As far as graphics cards go, there's really no better company right now. It's mostly personal preference. If you're looking for top of the line card, check out the ATI X850XT and the Nvidia 6800GT.
 

Descent

Hella Constipated
7,686
109
157
#5
Junglizm said:
ATI X850XT
You get the same amount of performance for less with the X800 XL! Also, the XL is only $300, usually around $280.

Oh, and it can be passively cooled.
 

BRiT

CRaZY
Founder
11,662
2,402
487
#6
Descent said:
You get the same amount of performance for less with the X800 XL! Also, the XL is only $300, usually around $280.

Oh, and it can be passively cooled.
I'm sure Jung knows that, hence why he said "IF you're looking for TOP OF THE LINE card..."

And you do not get the same amount of performance, you get a percentage of it. It falls off in higher-res/aa/af settings when compared to the X850XT. But the Best Bang-per-buck is the GF 6800 GT / ATI X800 XL realm, depending on connectors (AGP / PCI-Express). I think MWave has the X800 XL PCI-Express for around $250.
 

Descent

Hella Constipated
7,686
109
157
#7
BRiT said:
TOP OF THE LINE card..."
My bad...I was (and still am!) REALLY fucking tired :D. I missed that sentence.