Headlines singapore
- Thread starter dsj
- Start date
(I assume you're referring to the incident where the teenager vandalised a police car in Singapore.)
If that is the case, then the little fucker deserved it. As I remember, he was the son of an American ambassador or some shit and thought he could do whatever the fuck he wanted, since he thought that America wouldn't let them punish him. Serves the little prick right.
If that is the case, then the little fucker deserved it. As I remember, he was the son of an American ambassador or some shit and thought he could do whatever the fuck he wanted, since he thought that America wouldn't let them punish him. Serves the little prick right.
We had a debate about this in my Government class. If he had done the same thing in the United States, what would he have gotten? probably a few months in jail. I was surprised to hear several of my classmates say that, given the option, they'd rather take a few lashes than lose their freedom for a long period of time.
We have the death penalty in the United States. I'm sure that would be considered as a violation of human rights by someone in another country, but here it's the norm, just as caning is the norm in Singapore. It isn't our place to criticize another country's legal system any more than it is their place to criticize ours.
In your opinion caning is wrong, but it's sorta asinine to think that you can dictate standards of morality to people living half a world away. They do what works best for them. Singapore has low crime rates, so they're obviously doing something right. If people are afraid of a painful punishment, then they are far less likely to commit a crime than when they know all they'll get is a fine and/or jail time.
The human rights charter applies to all humans. No beating and degrading punishments. You can kill people for stealing a dollar then the crime rate would be really low. But that is a police state, not a free society. America has the right to protect it's citizens from brutal situations.
http://www.corpun.com/awfay9405.htm
"After the fourth and final stroke, say Singapore officials, Fay shook hands with his caner and insisted on walking back to his cell unaided. He wanted to act like a man."
Oh wow, he must have been so shocked from the brutality of his punishment that he was delirious, that's the only thing that could explain his taking the punishment so well.
"After the fourth and final stroke, say Singapore officials, Fay shook hands with his caner and insisted on walking back to his cell unaided. He wanted to act like a man."
Oh wow, he must have been so shocked from the brutality of his punishment that he was delirious, that's the only thing that could explain his taking the punishment so well.
some babbler said:
really?
so what about war? what about abu ghraib? ahahah..
do you really think that the "human rights charter" has any power over anything?
you're talking like some amnesty international representative. the truth about what you can and cannot do isn't a piece of paper. it's what happens in reality.
kid breaks local law, kid suffers local punishment. i have no complaints. he's an american citizen? BIG FUCKING DEAL; SINGAPORE ISN'T AN AMERICAN STATE. maybe if he obeyed the rules he wouldn't have been punished.
you could argue that jail is inhumane as easily as you could argue that corporal punishment is inhumane.
the problem is that you're ignoring one simple fact: a guy broke a law and suffered the punishment that law carries. "police state" or not, singapore is sovereign and it was his own damn fault.
~ dan ~
dsj said:
at least we support our arguments.
if you really want to go there, please allow me to annihilate you.
here in america, access to health care is not universal. thus, the most modern country on earth is inhumane because basic human rights are not being met.
~ dan ~
dsj said:
And that's why their country is much more disciplined than the U.S. not that I agree...... But if we imposed stricter laws on vandalism and teens going through their Rebel (growing pains) stage things may be a lot different!
Kids can be cruel and ARE assholes! I was one...and I was a PUNK. I always knew that I would get of easy.....and if you think about it, it's true....None of our laws even register to some other countries. On the same note that may be considered cruel and unusual punishment?
Fuck that PUNK any way Defacing some ones personal property is fuct! especially when it's a car! That's wrong! U don't fuck with some one's ride..
Yeah, what Twist said. Harsher penalties, bigger deterrent. I'm not talking prison here. Like those arab countries, (excuse me for generalising, I don't know the particular name) where they chop your hand off for stealing.
You will think twice about doing that again. As will the dumb american whose whining about a few canes. He'll remember he got beats for doing it, and will think again.
At least he wont be locked in a small room with a big sweaty bloke called Bubba.
</rant>
You will think twice about doing that again. As will the dumb american whose whining about a few canes. He'll remember he got beats for doing it, and will think again.
At least he wont be locked in a small room with a big sweaty bloke called Bubba.
</rant>
And who the fuck exactly are you to make that determination? Just because we have different opinions than you means we "don't deserve to live?"dsj said:
You speak of the human rights charter and how human life is precious and shit like that, then you turn around and say this?
I smell a fucking hippocrite.
-
Want to get something off your chest? You've found the right place! To learn more about our site, please visit our About Us section.
Registration takes less than 30 seconds to gain access to posting, and many other hidden features available. Why not create your free account today directly or via Google, Facebook, or Twitter?